The naked information of the case forged American teenager William Leslie Arnold as a murderous villain who shot his dad and mom as a result of they refused to let him take their automobile to a drive-in in 1958.
Then simply 16 years previous, Arnold buried their our bodies within the yard of the household’s dwelling in Omaha, Nebraska, and went about life as regular for 2 weeks, till he was confronted and confessed to a criminal offense that noticed him sentenced to life in jail.
From there, Arnold’s story may have adopted the acquainted path of a lifer — many years of incarceration earlier than a dying famous by some and mourned by few.
However Arnold’s escape from jail, whereas nonetheless a younger man in 1967, led to a very totally different end result that ended incongruously in Australia, and the dying of a person by a distinct title, who was often known as a loving father to a household who had no concept about his secret life.
The murders
Black and white press pictures from the Nineteen Fifties present a slight boy being led into the backyard of his dwelling, surrounded by law enforcement officials as he pointed to the place he buried his dad and mom.
Geoff Britton, chief of the Workplace of Legislation Enforcement Help in California, recollects particulars of the case with the vivid recollection of somebody who has spent years poring over the recordsdata.
The evening of the murders, Arnold shot his dad and mom earlier than taking the automobile and watching a double function along with his highschool girlfriend earlier than telling everybody — even relations — that his dad and mom had taken a visit.
“He had killed his dad and mom. And he was going to bury them within the yard later that evening and he’s on the drive-in seeing ‘The Undead,'” mentioned Britton, who labored on the case for 9 years from 2004 to 2013 on the State of Nebraska Division of Correctional Providers.
“To kill your dad and mom over using the automobile to go to the flicks — that’s not regular. It made me marvel if one thing else was happening,” he instructed CNN.
By the point Britton began on the case, Arnold had been on the run for greater than three many years.
In 1967, after serving simply eight years of his life sentence, Arnold and a fellow inmate, James Harding, communicated with somebody on the surface, by newspaper ads positioned in native newspaper, the Lincoln Journal Star, Britton mentioned.
“I used to be capable of establish the individual that helped them get the gear to get out of jail — it was a former parolee,” mentioned Britton, explaining that the parolee obtained masks the prisoners used to idiot guards who carried out day by day head counts on the jail.
“Just like the film ‘Escape from Alcatraz’ with Clint Eastwood,” Britton added.
Newspaper stories on the time documented their daring escape over a 12-foot excessive wire fence within the low-security space of the jail, utilizing a T-shirt to cowl the barbed wire.
A floor and air search prolonged throughout 4 states with helicopters, fixed-wing plane, patrol troopers, sheriff’s deputies and law enforcement officials, based on an article within the Lincoln Journal Star dated July 15, 1967. Three months later, the Omaha World-Herald quoted a jail warden as saying theirs was the “cleanest” escape in his expertise.
Britton mentioned investigators later found the escapees made it to Omaha, then caught a bus to Chicago, the place they parted methods, based on Harding, who was captured inside one 12 months.
Arnold appeared to have vanished.
Over time, investigators adopted quite a few leads, together with rumour that he had fled to South America, although they discovered no proof that he was ever there.
Britton grew to become so obsessive about the case, he continued investigating it even when he moved away from Nebraska — and he was later put in contact with Matthew Westover, a deputy United States Marshal in Nebraska, who instructed CNN he took over the file in 2020.
“One of many guys left the workplace, and (whenever you depart) you need to hand over your instances. So certainly one of my buddies gave me this case, as form of a joke, you recognize, like ‘you’re by no means going discover this man,'” Westover mentioned.
Westover learn tales within the Omaha World-Herald by reporter Henry J. Cordes, who coated the case extensively in a sequence titled “The Thriller of Leslie Arnold.”
By way of quite a few interviews, Cordes discovered a extra difficult story than some had been led to consider. Within the sequence, he portrayed Arnold as a great scholar who had a tough relationship along with his dad and mom. The capturing, wrote Cordes, got here after a heated argument between Arnold and his mom, who disapproved of his girlfriend.
In jail, Arnold adopted the foundations and will have certified for early launch, Cordes wrote. He was a devoted musician and the jail music room the place he spent a lot of his time actually grew to become his window of escape.
Together with the masks, the parolee threw hacksaws over the fence, which Arnold and Harding used to chop by the bars on the window earlier than scaling the fence, based on Cordes.
The extra Westover learn, the extra satisfied he grew to become that he was the person to seek out Arnold.
“From day one, I used to be hooked,” he mentioned.
How the regulation closed in on Arnold
By the point the case had landed on Westover’s desk the world had modified.
Arnold might have used categorised advertisements to rearrange his escape from jail, however many years on, crimes had been not solved by poring over previous newspapers.
By 2020, DNA testing had develop into commonplace, so Westover received within the automobile and drove 5 hours throughout the border to seek out James Arnold, William Leslie Arnold’s younger brother.
James Arnold wasn’t dwelling when the murders had been dedicated, however greater than 60 years later he was joyful to adjust to a request from Westover for a DNA pattern, which the US Marshal uploaded to an ancestry web site. It didn’t return something helpful.
Undeterred, Westover sought out previous FBI recordsdata and used Britton’s earlier analysis to attempt to piece collectively Arnold’s actions.
As Westover dug deeper, the DNA pattern he’d uploaded in 2020 lastly hit a match. In 2022, Westover obtained an alert that James Arnold’s DNA had matched with one other pattern with sufficient similarities to be an in depth relative.
“I observed instantly that I had a match that was means larger than something I’d had earlier than. It was mainly precisely what I used to be in search of,” mentioned Westover, who instantly reported the discovering to Britton.
Westover mentioned he additionally obtained an e mail from the person who had uploaded it. “It mentioned, ‘Hey, I’m looking for out extra details about my father. He was an orphan from Chicago.'”
“So I move that on to Geoff and I used to be like, ‘that is the man. There’s no means this isn’t the man.”
The person behind the e-mail
The person that despatched the e-mail was Arnold’s son, whose id each Westover and Britton are cautious to guard.
Westover mentioned the son didn’t know he’d emailed a US Marshal who’d been tasked with monitoring down his father. Westover mentioned the son assumed he was a member of the family, as he’d used James Arnolds’ title to add the DNA.
The son mentioned he needed to know extra about his father, who he knew as John Damon, who died in 2010.
Westover mentioned he engaged in very cautious correspondence, in order to not probably alert Arnold that the regulation was closing in — if he was, actually, nonetheless alive.
“If he’s this good, and he was capable of elude police for 50 years, who’s to say he didn’t pretend his dying and all of the pictures?” Westover requested.
Westover mentioned he was lastly satisfied that Arnold was useless when native officers confirmed a dying certificates — and that’s when Westover knew he needed to inform Arnold’s son the small print of his father’s darkest secret.
“I felt responsible. I imply, he’s giving me all this data. And right here I'm holding the important thing to what he wanted,” mentioned Westover.
“And on the identical time, I’m additionally form of pressed towards the clock as a result of he’s telling me that he’s reaching out to all these different relations as effectively that he doesn’t know.”
Westover mentioned he needed to be the one to inform him about his father, and he organized a video name with the person and his spouse. “I simply needed to make it possible for he wasn’t alone as a result of, I imply, there’s loads to tackle,” he mentioned.
Westover mentioned he made the decision from his automobile, as he sat in his driveway, by way of a cellphone propped up on the dashboard.
“I confirmed him who I used to be… then he requested me what (his father) did to be in jail. So I needed to inform him,” he mentioned. “I instructed him, ‘Properly, he was an orphan. He didn’t lie about that, however he killed his dad and mom, that’s why he was an orphan.'”
William Leslie Arnold — aka John Damon — died age 69 and was laid to relaxation in Australia, 1000's of miles from the fortified partitions of Nebraska State Penitentiary, the place he would possibly in any other case have ended his days.
Now that they know his alias, US officers are piecing collectively Arnold’s life from his final identified location in Chicago.
Westover says Arnold modified his title a couple of months after escaping from jail in 1967. Britton says he received a job in a restaurant, the place he met his first spouse and have become a father to her 4 youngsters.
Investigators say they then moved to Cincinnati, Miami and Los Angeles earlier than divorcing in 1978. Information present that Arnold moved to New Zealand within the Nineties, then Australia later the identical decade, Westover mentioned.
Britton mentioned his household, together with his second spouse, had no data of his former life.
“My coronary heart goes out to that total household,” he mentioned.
Westover says in some methods, he’s relieved Arnold is useless — after assembly his household, he wouldn't wish to have sought his arrest and deportation to the US.
Britton feels the identical.
“The police officer in me at all times needed to arrest him and convey him in. However you recognize, that wasn’t the result,” he mentioned.
“However I gotta let you know, I've spoken to his household a number of instances now. They're an unimaginable household. And I gained’t say a lot about them out of privateness issues, however what I'll say is that this …
“I feel finally he grew to become the guardian who he needed to be, or the one he wished he had.
“As a result of from all the things I’ve observed, it looks as if he was a great supplier and a great father. He raised some fairly nice children.”
Arnold’s son, who requested to not be recognized to guard his household’s privateness, declined to be interviewed for this piece, however offered CNN with a press release that reads:
“There’s no warning label on the DNA check package telling you that you just won't like what you discover,” he mentioned. “However I don’t remorse doing it, and I’m glad I now know the reality about my dad.
“Though it’s stunning to know that his life started with a horrible crime, his legacy is a lot greater than that.
“I need him to be remembered for being a great father and supplier to us, and instilling in me a ardour for music, and a drive to at all times be the most effective individual I will be.”
The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2023 Cable Information Community, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Firm. All rights reserved.