Click on right here for an entire record of our election suggestions.
Antioch metropolis management is in turmoil.
With an investigation concluding that the mayor sexually harassed subordinates and an ongoing FBI prison probe involving metropolis cops, the necessity for mature, educated and cooperative leaders on the Metropolis Council is larger than ever.
Leaders who also can bridge the widening political divide between the Metropolis Council’s conservative and progressive factions; who can search for options to town’s monetary, homeless and police challenges; and who acknowledge that addressing town’s future housing wants ought to concentrate on transit-oriented infill somewhat than perpetuating 4 a long time of auto-dependent sprawl.
For that, voters within the Nov. 8 election ought to forged ballots for Pleasure Motts in District 1, on the northern aspect of town, and Shawn Pickett in District 4, on the southern finish. Whoever wins, the challenges forward is not going to be simple.
We and two members of the Metropolis Council have known as for the elected mayor, Lamar Thorpe, who shouldn't be up for election this yr, to resign, and a few of his political allies have damagedties to him. The investigation report, launched final week, sustained allegations that Thorpe grabbed the buttock of 1 lady and the naked leg of one other final yr when he was govt director of a troubled well being care district.
In the meantime, eight of town’s cops are underneath federal investigation for civil rights violations and different offenses. The police chief is conducting an evaluation of the division’s use of police canine after this information group reported that a K9 officer’s canine had bitten 22 folks over the previous three years.
And the Police Division faces a staffing scarcity as a result of the eight officers underneath investigation are on depart and since Antioch, like many cities, is struggling to rent cops. Town is so determined that it’s providing $30,000 signing bonuses for lateral hires. The record of challenges additionally consists of town’s homeless downside and projected funds shortfalls over the subsequent three to 4 years.
District 1: Pleasure Motts
Motts was elected in a citywide race in 2018, two years earlier than the Metropolis Council switched to district elections. Consequently, she needed to run once more in 2020 and misplaced the District 1 election to Tamisha Torres-Walker.
Now the 2 are competing once more. We thought Motts was the superior candidate in 2020, and we haven’t modified our thoughts. She’s clear about the necessity to beef up Police Division staffing and educated concerning the metropolis’s funds, which she understands have to be rigorously managed. She additionally acknowledges the necessity to focus housing building on in-fill improvement.
In her time period on the council, she labored to search out options for town’s homeless. And he or she’s supportive of the way to enhance police response with alternate options similar to psychological well being staff.
As for Torres-Walker, she proposes a tax on vacant items within the metropolis however doesn’t present knowledge to help the thought. And he or she doesn’t totally recognize the potential monetary troubles that lie forward for town. These coverage variations alone can be sufficient for us to help Motts over Torres-Walker.
Then there’s Torres-Walker’s private habits that has helped make her a polarizing member of the council. She was accused of obstructing or resisting a metropolis police officer responding in October 2021 to a capturing name in her neighborhood, however the misdemeanor costs had been later dropped.
Earlier, in a December 2020 incident, quickly after Torres-Walker’s election, Antioch police stopped her 23-year-old and 13-year-old sons for using off-road automobiles on metropolis streets. In a tearful, profanity-laced video, wherein she repeatedly refers to her place as a council member, Torres-Walker accuses the officers of overreacting and making an attempt to run over the youthful son and later handcuffing him after her older son escaped.
She has stated that she and her kids had been “focused” by Antioch police. Given the continuing FBI investigation of the Police Division, we’re definitely not dismissing her declare. However her video response was past the pale for an elected official.
She now says she needs she had reacted in another way and says she was afraid for her sons. That’s comprehensible. However, as she says, since then “I’ve been making an attempt to determine what a constructive working relationship appears like between me and our native Police Division.”
It’s essential that each one Metropolis Council members have such working relationships. But it’s been a yr since her video tirade — sufficient time to determine that relationship. Clearly, that’s unlikely to occur.
As for the third candidate within the race, Diane Gibson-Grey, a former college board trustee who ran unsuccessfully for Metropolis Council in 2016, her insistence that town approve extra high-end housing to draw employers echoes a futile cry we’ve heard for 4 a long time from those that champion sprawling development.
District 4: Shawn Pickett
Pickett is a retired Richmond Police lieutenant who advocates for reform of Antioch’s policing. He’s clear that the division wants to extend its staffing and advocates for a civilian supervisor overseeing inside affairs and an exterior civilian oversight panel, somewhat than the present politically charged Metropolis Council oversight.
He’s proper when he says that, of the candidates and council members, nobody has expertise coping with a police division in transition as he does.
To make sure, Pickett’s tenure on the Richmond Police Division was not all rosy. He and 6 different Black members of the division misplaced a discrimination lawsuit towards town and Chris Magnus, the extremely regarded police chief who went on to turn out to be President Biden’s commissioner of the U.S. Customs and Border Safety.
However, Pickett is the strongest of the 4 candidates on this Metropolis Council race. He’s very aware and rightfully involved concerning the metropolis’s projected funds shortfalls and its unfunded pension liabilities. And he’s clear, and proper, that the mayor ought to resign.
In distinction, there’s incumbent Monica Wilson, first elected in 2012 and the longest-serving present member of the Metropolis Council. She is a part of the council’s progressive faction however the least controversial and most probably to collaborate with opponents.
However, relating to the mayor, Wilson has put political allegiances first. Wilson shortly jumped to the protection of Thorpe, who's Black, when the sexual harassment allegations arose. She branded requires his resignation “racially divisive grandstanding” by his opponents — which was particularly troubling contemplating she later admitted she hadn’t even learn the allegations earlier than making the feedback.
Then, she added, “Though they don't prefer it, we're now not the Antioch of 1876. We're a racially various group that embraces everybody’s viewpoint.” She’s proper, however that’s not justification for Thorpe’s habits.
Even after the discharge final week of the investigation that discovered Thorpe had sexually harassed his subordinates, Wilson stood silent, saying solely that she wouldn’t be “pulled into the center of this.” That silence, that refusal to name out Thorpe and rise up for ladies victims, is particularly troubling provided that Wilson’s day job is working to assist people who find themselves victims of human trafficking.
The true check of management is whether or not one is keen to make the morally proper choice even when it’s politically tough. On that, Wilson failed.
This race additionally consists of Councilwoman Lori Ogorchock, who attributable to council redistricting is now additionally in District 4. If she doesn’t win, Ogorchock will retain her present District 3 seat till the 2024 election. Like Thorpe and Torres-Walker, Ogorchock could be a polarizing particular person on the council, however from the conservative aspect.
The opposite candidate within the race is Sandra White, a human relations govt, whose meandering solutions had been onerous to parse for substantive solutions.