Kurtenbach: The good, the bad, and the 49ers’ big question after Trey Lance’s season opener

The TV digital camera angle didn’t do the throw justice, and it regarded fairly cool on TV.

Trey Lance, the 49ers’ first-year beginning quarterback, took a second-down, second-quarter snap, faked a handoff to operating again Elijah Mitchell, and feigned one other to sweeping huge receiver Deebo Samuel, planted his again foot, bounced in place, and ripped a 30-yard throw over two Bears defenders, instantly into the chest of his teammate Ray-Ray McCloud, who was chopping throughout the sector, proper to left.

It was the sort of move we've got not seen a 49ers quarterback make since Kyle Shanahan took over as head coach — the proper mixture of energy and contact.

And whereas Lance’s throw to McCloud wasn’t the perfect throw of this NFL weekend, the corporate he stored in that competitors — Patrick Mahomes, Justin Herbert — confirmed the younger quarterback’s unbelievable potential.

This child has an opportunity to be particular.

If solely all of Lance’s throws had been like that on Sunday.

Lance’s efficiency in opposition to the Bears was the proper encapsulation of what we should always count on from the quarterback who the Niners nonetheless take into account a rookie.

Up and down. Good and dangerous. Feast and famine.

Lance could make throws that may pull you out of your seat.

He can observe that with a throw that may make you cowl your face.

This isn’t a novel place for younger quarterbacks to seek out themselves. That is fairly regular.

However the 49ers’ circumstances are something however regular. Lance is taking up a staff that was 1 / 4 away from the Tremendous Bowl final season, with the quarterback of that staff nonetheless on the roster.

No strain, child, simply be adequate to take this staff excessive of an already steep mountain.

The 49ers have handed Lance the beginning job as a result of they (rightfully) imagine he has the expertise to do it.

He might lose the beginning job (in a couple of months) if he doesn’t put all of it collectively quickly sufficient.

The reality is that there is no such thing as a excellent calibration between good and dangerous for Lance. That’s as a result of perfection is the objective of any quarterback, and that may by no means actually be reached.

Nevertheless it’s onerous to make the case that Lance had extra good than dangerous in Sunday’s season opener, even when the great popped off the display.

Along with the spectacular throw to McCloud, Lance had top-flight throws to tight finish Ross Dwelley, Brandon Aiyuk, and Jauan Jennings.

However you would possibly wish to apply that deference for Lance’s misses. There was a throw behind Jennings, a missed landing to Tyler Kroft, and a game-losing interception that can't be sugar-coated.

Blame the offensive line or the downpour that drenched the fourth quarter, however earlier than that fourth-quarter interception, Lance was 9-for-16. He accomplished solely one among each three throws he made after that (4-of-12).

Now, Lance, to his credit score, put the loss on his shoulders after the sport. His maturity is among the causes the Niners are betting on him.

And the younger quarterback additionally was stable within the run sport Sunday. That’s an underrated issue contemplating the climate, even when he confirmed the propensity to tuck and run too shortly, as he did in his two spot begins final 12 months.

It was a Rorschach check of a sport — the sort of sport Garoppolo had numerous instances throughout his tenure because the 49ers’ starter. It lives within the subjective realm.

How do you calibrate the great in opposition to the dangerous?

With Garoppolo, the great wasn’t big-time throws, however as a substitute, a copious variety of stable tosses over the center, countered by jaw-dropping errors.

With Lance, it’s dabbling within the spectacular with clear-cut reminders of his inexperience alongside the way in which.

The excellent news for Lance is that he's simply starting his journey as an NFL quarterback. Garoppolo constantly confirmed that he had reached his potential in San Francisco. That’s an enormous motive why he’s nonetheless on the staff and why a quarterback change is ridiculous to think about after only one sport.

However the rising pains for Lance are actual, and whereas they had been anticipated, on Sunday, the staff didn’t play nicely sufficient to insulate itself from these errors. The scoreboard informed the reality.

Shifting ahead, the Niners want extra from everybody, together with Lance. However with quarterback being an important place on the sector, you — sure, you — need to reply the identical query the 49ers’ brass has been asking for the reason that second the sport ended. It’s the identical query the staff has requested for the final 5 years:

If the remainder of the staff doesn’t play one thing near an ideal sport, can the Niners win with an imperfect quarterback?

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post