/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/70531290/merlin_2652454.0.jpg)
Final week, I learn an opinion column within the Deseret Information opposing Senate Invoice 49, which seeks to broaden state incentives to draw movie productions to Utah. Oddly sufficient, as an elected commissioner in San Juan County who has labored laborious to assist move SB49, I might usually agree with a lot of the factors the author made.
He argued that, in an ideal world, authorities wouldn't present tax breaks or subsidies to non-public business. Laborious to disagree. He reasoned that a part of the issue is that too many states are providing incentives to the movie enterprise, which forces Utah to contemplate upping its efforts. I can’t argue with that.
He famous that there's debate amongst economists as as to if these tax incentive packages are price it. That jogged my memory of an outdated joke that for those who took all of the economists on this planet and laid them end-to-end, they nonetheless wouldn’t attain a conclusion. Little doubt there's disagreement.
The piece additionally said that Michigan’s movie incentive program was so unhealthy, it was canceled. That could be a truth, and if Utah’s program was something in any respect like Michigan’s, I might cancel it, too.
The late, nice Rush Limbaugh used to declare himself “Mayor of Realville.” Properly, perhaps I ought to run for county commissioner there, as a result of actuality for my county could be very totally different from what was portrayed within the article. Our county has been damage badly by the losses in movie productions over the previous few years. It’s not like a brand new Tesla manufacturing facility is on its strategy to Blanding, so movie manufacturing dollars actually matter.
SB49 doesn't create a brand new program. Utah presently has a viable, well-managed tax-incentive program to draw movie productions, particularly to rural Utah. From the beginning, the Legislature properly imposed a “cap” on the quantity that may very well be rebated at $8.3 million. They needed this system to show itself. It labored nicely sufficient that the cap is now too low and we're shedding enterprise to different states.
One other good transfer by lawmakers was to limit tax rebates solely to cash paid on to Utah contractors, items and providers. Michigan, for one, didn't try this. In Utah, the one manufacturing dollars eligible for a tax rebate are these spent on Utah individuals, items and providers.
Moreover, Utah solely approves rebates after the cash has been spent. Nobody will get a Utah rebate primarily based on guarantees or predictions; rebates solely come after the actual fact, following cautious audits and approvals.
I assume taking a poke at Kevin Costner, a widely known star and producer, was too tempting to move up, however he is just one (vital) participant in a large business. I believe most Utahns would say that if Costner needs to return right here and spend, say, a $20 million chunk of his general price range hiring, renting and buying proper right here in Utah, and in return for every tax greenback owed on these native expenditures we rebate 20 cents, that’s not a nasty deal. Now we now have 80 cents we'd have gotten no different means.
SB49 leaves the $8.3 million cap in place, however does enable it to rise for productions that particularly profit Utah’s rural counties. For tax rebates to exceed the cap, the vast majority of the manufacturing should happen in rural Utah and generate sufficient jobs, native enterprise revenues and taxes to boost it. The thought is that exceeding the prevailing cap could be an excellent factor, particularly for rural Utah.
Some individuals additionally wrongly assume that the one means Utah can compete is by providing greater tax rebates than another state. That isn't true, neither is that the purpose. Utah has built-in benefits that different states don’t have, like a world airport/Delta hub. Utah boasts an unbeatable vary of landscapes. We provide over 3,000 lively Utah unbiased movie manufacturing contractors — in lighting, images, units, transportation, and so on. — and 1000's of companies all through the state that profit from the spending.
Utah is just not trying to out-incentivize different states or win the proverbial “race to the underside.” If the rebate cap rises, it can imply rural Utah is the large winner. If we're fairly aggressive on value, we will shut the hole with our different points of interest. However we will’t win the enterprise if we make it unattainable for a producer who needs to work right here to remain on price range.
Like most of us, I might like to dwell in a spot the place every thing is because it “ought to” be. Sadly, none of us does. Am I completely happy that generally authorities intervenes to assist its constituents prosper? Probably not. It ought to solely occur when really vital and the advantages clearly outweigh the prices. For my part, SB49 qualifies.
Bruce Adams is a San Juan County commissioner, a former educator, and a lifelong cowboy. He lives in Monticello, Utah.